TOLKIEN - FOLLY HILL AND FOLLY TOWER ... Compelling evidence now points to a remarkable conclusion: Folly Hill is none other than Tolkien’s own Hobbiton Hill, and the Folly Tower is the Tower of Orthanc/Isengard --Saruman’s Tower. To seasoned Tolkien fans, this isn’t just plausible; It almost borders on the obvious. “As an Oxford don, this landscape was Tolkien's backyard—barely twenty miles from home. He walked these Downs constantly, often with his friend Jack Lewis: White Horse Hill, Dragon Hill, Wayland’s Smithy - all well documented. He would have passed close to Faringdon countless times. And given his fondness for towers, Folly Hill and Folly Tower would have been irresistible to him .” But “bordering on the obvious” still isn’t the same as compelling evidence. For years, the clues were scattered—word‑of‑mouth, conjecture, circumstantial scraps, half‑remembered anecdotes. Confetti in the wind. Then, only fairly recently, the pieces all clicked together. They don't just fit—they clearly form a single, compelling, coherent picture and narrative, that tells the same story over and again. And that story is: This beautiful quiet corner of the Vale of the White Horse is, quite simply, the Shire of Tolkien’s Middle‑earth. Anyway, we’ll let you decide how compelling you think this evidence is. Click on the puzzle pieces to find out more: |
Easily recognisable as Tolkien’s beloved Hobbiton Hill, this iconic painting from 1937 has a charming trick up its sleeve.
Show it to anyone from Hatford—that tiny hamlet tucked southeast of Folly Hill—and you might hear a knowing chuckle: “That’s Holy Trinity Church in the foreground, Sandy Lane curling away from us, and Folly Hill rising in the distance. And that must be Manor House Farm on the left of Sandy Lane. But he's missed out the Hatford Down cottages on the corner” . Is this the middle‑earth Shire they're talking about - or rural Oxfordshire? For them, it’s no contest. They're one and the same. |
Home in Hatford named "Rivendell" BEFORE publication of The Hobbit in 1937
Interview with Jack Fox: Tower construction was his playground in 1935.
Tolkien and the Tower are inextricably linked. John Garth - Tolkien expert - explains.
|
Old wallpaper peeled back to reveal Tolkien drawings
How the Folly Tower Timeline slots into the Tolkien Timeline
Comparing the Shire Map with the OS Map - using Hobbiton Hill/Folly Hill as anchor.
|
Hobbiton-Across-The-Water is view of Folly Hill from Hatford
Hobbiton Hill profile identical to 1786 engraving
Tolkien comes clean: Hobbiton is approximately the latitude of Oxford.
|
SUMMARY
RIVENDELL: A bungalow in Hatford mysteriously named Rivendell three years before the publication of The Hobbit
WALLPAPER: A redecorated Hatford bungalow revealed Tolkien‑style drawings hidden beneath 1930s wallpaper,
HILL PICTURE: Hatford locals see Hobbiton Hill and Folly Hill as the very same place,
JACK FOX: Memories include a pipe‑smoking “prof” who sketched dragons and chatted with Lord Berners
TIMELINE: Timelines align - placing Tolkien, Lord Berners, Folly Tower and Rivendell all in the mid‑1930s
PROFILE: A near‑perfect match between Hobbiton Hill and Folly Hill’s 1786 profile
GARTH: Tolkien was deeply tower‑obsessed, sympathetic to Lord Berners, and saw in Faringdon Folly a real‑world echo of Orthanc
OS MAP: Uncanny alignment between Tolkien’s Shire map and the local OS map
LATITUDE: Tolkien confirms the intended latitude of the Shire as being aligned with Folly/Hobbiton Hill
WALLPAPER: A redecorated Hatford bungalow revealed Tolkien‑style drawings hidden beneath 1930s wallpaper,
HILL PICTURE: Hatford locals see Hobbiton Hill and Folly Hill as the very same place,
JACK FOX: Memories include a pipe‑smoking “prof” who sketched dragons and chatted with Lord Berners
TIMELINE: Timelines align - placing Tolkien, Lord Berners, Folly Tower and Rivendell all in the mid‑1930s
PROFILE: A near‑perfect match between Hobbiton Hill and Folly Hill’s 1786 profile
GARTH: Tolkien was deeply tower‑obsessed, sympathetic to Lord Berners, and saw in Faringdon Folly a real‑world echo of Orthanc
OS MAP: Uncanny alignment between Tolkien’s Shire map and the local OS map
LATITUDE: Tolkien confirms the intended latitude of the Shire as being aligned with Folly/Hobbiton Hill
NEW NARRATIVE....
“In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit…” thus begins the story of our brave little adventurer Bilbo. In 1929, when Tolkien first penned these words, there was probably no link in his fertile mind with any physical location - apart from the composite of Tolkien’s homes and happy memories perhaps. Home is where the heart is. The reader is given the freedom to feel that Hobbiton is also the reader’s home.
But then, in 1934, three years before the Hobbit was first published, something happened that profoundly changed this. Tolkien became very interested in a new tower that was being built on a hill in the north western corner of what was then Berkshire. He visited this tower regularly during the construction, and he regularly stayed at weekends in a simple three-room bothy, in a field just two miles down the hill, in the little hamlet of Hatford. There were no connected utilities; electricity hadn’t reached Hatford yet, and water came from a well behind the bothy. And he called his weekend bolthole Rivendell. It was his weekend retreat. His place of refuge.
Over the next few years, he would walk up from Hatford to Folly Hill and Folly Tower along Frogmore Brook as it meanders through the canopy of gnarled old-man willows, and he would see the hill looming closer as he approached across the fields. His final approach up Folly Hill would have taken him through the middle of the "Party Field". This view of the hill must have made a significant and lasting impression on him, because when we look at Tolkien’s iconic image of Hobbiton Hill, first sketched out in January 1937, we see clearly that it’s Folly Hill. The view from Hatford.
And, as he developed his middle-earth geography (for example, when he added “The Shire” in 1938) he was now clearly using Folly Hill as his anchor.
But then, in 1934, three years before the Hobbit was first published, something happened that profoundly changed this. Tolkien became very interested in a new tower that was being built on a hill in the north western corner of what was then Berkshire. He visited this tower regularly during the construction, and he regularly stayed at weekends in a simple three-room bothy, in a field just two miles down the hill, in the little hamlet of Hatford. There were no connected utilities; electricity hadn’t reached Hatford yet, and water came from a well behind the bothy. And he called his weekend bolthole Rivendell. It was his weekend retreat. His place of refuge.
Over the next few years, he would walk up from Hatford to Folly Hill and Folly Tower along Frogmore Brook as it meanders through the canopy of gnarled old-man willows, and he would see the hill looming closer as he approached across the fields. His final approach up Folly Hill would have taken him through the middle of the "Party Field". This view of the hill must have made a significant and lasting impression on him, because when we look at Tolkien’s iconic image of Hobbiton Hill, first sketched out in January 1937, we see clearly that it’s Folly Hill. The view from Hatford.
And, as he developed his middle-earth geography (for example, when he added “The Shire” in 1938) he was now clearly using Folly Hill as his anchor.
